What is the Work?
Ace Attorney is a franchise centered around a series of adventure video games developed and published by Capcom.
Who is the Candidate?
Miles Edgeworth is a character of Ace Attorney series. He is initially an antagonist before becoming a supporting character.
Simon Blackquill is a character of Ace Attorney series. He is initially an antagonist before becoming a supporting character.
What Makes Miles Edgeworth a Shonen Rival?
Anti-Heroic/Anti-Villainous: Miles Edgeworth is trained by Manfred von Karma to become a ruthless prosecutor who would adopt questionable tactics to get a guilty verdict for the defendant. After he is defeated in court by Phoenix Wright, Miles Edgeworth is motivated by him and eventually becomes a prosecutor to seek the truth.
Honorable: Miles Edgeworth wanted to become a lawyer like his father when he was a pupil. Despite Manfred von Karma teaches him to become a ruthless prosecutor seeking to win, Miles Edgeworth refuses to intentionally use forged evidence, and, after Miles Edgeworth is motivated by Phoenix Wright, Miles Edgeworth abandons Manfred von Karma’s ideology and becomes honorable.
Tragic: Gregory Edgeworth, Miles Edgeworth's father, is killed by Manfred von Karma during the DL-6 incident. Manfred von Karma adopts Miles Edgeworth and trains him to become a ruthless prosecutor like Manfred von Karma. The death of his father also leaves Miles Edgeworth fear of earthquakes and elevators.
Intelligent: Miles Edgeworth is noted to be intelligent since his childhood. When Miles Edgeworth was a pupil, he won awards in school for various activities. Miles Edgeworth's intelligence allows him to become a famed prosecutor.
Naturally Talented: Miles Edgeworth has influences from Gregory Edgeworth, his father and a lawyer, and Manfred von Karma, a prosecutor, which allows him to understand the law and show his talent in law since his childhood.
Pursues a Big-End Goal: Before Miles Edgeworth is motivated by Phoenix Wright, Miles Edgeworth pursues to maintain his victory record in court. After Miles Edgeworth is motivated by Phoenix Wright, Miles Edgeworth pursues to seek the truth as a prosecutor and use the power of the law to save people.
Believes in the Power of Individual Strength: Miles Edgeworth has the tendency of resisting other people’s attempts to help him, though Miles Edgeworth actually receives help from other people and appreciates their help.
What Makes Simon Blackquill a Shonen Rival?
Anti-Heroic/Anti-Villainous: Simon Blackquill controversially adopts psychological manipulation in court as a prosecutor, earning him the nickname the "Twisted Samurai". Simon Blackquill attempts to protect Athena Cykes, who would eventually prove his innocence, and eventually proves the Phantom's guilty.
Honorable: Despite Simon Blackquill pretends to be an intimidating prosecutor, he cares Athena Cykes, which becomes one of the reasons why he claims himself to be the murder of Metis Cykes as it would protect Athena Cykes.
Tragic: Simon Blackquill is convicted and sentenced to death when he believes that Athena Cykes kills her mother Metis Cykes, and decides to claim that he is the murder in order to protect Athena Cykes and the psychological profile of the international spy only known as "the Phantom".
Intelligent: Simon Blackquill is capable of maintaining his false persona for seven years in order to protect Athena Cykes and mislead the Phantom.
Arrogant/Jerkish: Simon Blackquill has a dark sense of humor. His dark sense of humor is softened but still exists even after the Phantom is convicted.
Pursues a Big-End Goal: Simon Blackquill pursues an international spy only known as "the Phantom" to the extent that he is willing to be sentenced to death to protect Athena Cykes and mislead the Phantom.
Verdict?
I vote to Yes to both. Miles Edgeworth is Phoenix Wright's rival. Simon Blackquill is Athena Cykes' rival. Despite the shippers' claims, they and their rivals are not in romantic relationship in canon.